Enjoy our signature 4‑oz bakery‑style soft baked cookies, handcrafted in small batches and baked fresh for every preorder. Soft‑centered, golden‑edged, and made with simple, high‑quality ingredients, these cookies bring back that warm “grandma’s kitchen” nostalgia in every bite.

 All cookies are baked to order to ensure peak freshness.

Flavors - List your flavors in the special instructions at checkout. 

Chocolate Chip 

Oatmeal Raisin

Sugar Cookies

Snickerdoodle

Strawberry Creme

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut

Double Chocolate Chip

Chocolate Whoopie Pie

Pickup Options (Indiana Only)

• Beech Grove Farmers Market — Tuesdays Pick up your preorder directly at the Beech Grove Farmers Market between 10AM-1PM, 1300 Albany Street, Beech Grove, IN 46107. You’ll receive a confirmation message with exact pickup details once your order is ready.

• Indianapolis Farmers Market — Wednesdays Convenient mid‑week pickup at the Franciscan Indianapolis Farmers Market between 10AM-1PM, 5230 E. Stop 11 Road, Indianapolis, IN 46237. Your confirmation message will include your pickup window and booth location.

Shipping (Indiana Only)

We currently ship within the state of Indiana only. Cookies are packaged with care to maintain freshness during transit.

Why Our Cookies Stand Out

• Hand‑scooped, 4‑oz bakery‑style cookies

• Soft, thick, nostalgic flavors

• Freshly baked 

• Classic and rotating flavors available

• Perfect for gifting, events, or treating yourself

Important Notes

• Orders placed outside Indiana will be automatically canceled